Protein Ice Cream Recipe: How to make the easiest, most delicious Ninja Creami protein ice cream recipe! Using your Ninja Creami makes getting your protein in easy and also so yummy!

This post in on Protein Ice Cream Recipe.

HOW TO MAKE NINJA CREAMI PROTEIN ICE CREAM

Protein Ice Cream Ninja Creami

(Friends: This post has links included are affiliate links. Countess of Shopping & her furbabies will be compensated when you make a purchase by clicking through the links at no cost to you.) Of course, this is not medical advice & I am not a doctor. Check with your own doctor always. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

4 Ingredients Needed:

• 1) Ninja Creami
  • (ORDER NINJA CREAMI HERE)
• 2) Protein Shake
  • (WATCH WHICH PROTEIN SHAKES TO USE).
• 3) 1-2 Tablespoon of Sugar-Free Jell-o Pudding (Cheesecake or vanilla flavor)
  • (ORDER IN BULK HERE)
• 4) (Optional) Extra Ice Cream Container
  • (YOU WILL NEED EXTRAS FOR DIFFERET FLAVORS, ORDER HERE)

I have not used a DASH Ice Cream Maker, but to save on expenses that could be something to try vs Ninja Creami Ice Cream Maker.

Homemade Protein Ice Cream

1) Pour protein drink into Ninja Creami plastic container.

I love using Biocare Dietary Beverage Protein in chocolate or mixed fruit. Biocare Protein is specifically meant for people on GLP-1 Medications, which is one of the many reasons why I enjoy consuming them.

2) Mix in 1-2 tablespoons of Jello sugar free instant pudding mix. This will make your high protein ice cream thick.

You will need the sugar free Jello pudding to make the mixture thicker. I used a milk frother to ensure thoroughly mixed together.

3) Freeze container with mixture for at least 24 hours.

4) Get your Ninja Creami out. Make sure your mixture is not past the plastic ice cream container line and also flat. If the frozen mixture is not flat, take a knife to make it smooth.

Mine usually have a bubble in the middle. Cut that off to ensure the ice cream is flat or it could break your Ninja Creami.

🎥 (WATCH HERE) HOW TO MAKE🎥

5) Then mix with Ninja Creami and bon appteti!

If your first spin comes out dry and flaky, simply hit remix button and put in for a second spin.

Also, I let my ice cream mixture sit on the kitchen counter for 5-10 minutes to thaw a little bit before mixing to prevent ‘dry dust’ texture from the first spin. This will ensure the protein ice cream comes out velvety and creamy.

Ninja Creami Ice Cream Flavors

There are so many flavors to choose from. And it’s a great way to get protein in!

You can easily change out to make different flavors:

• Protein Drink – fill almost up to line in your plastic pint container. I use two Biocare Dietary Beverage Protein packets per Ninja container.
• Jello Instant Mixture – use 1-2 tablespoons

By changing the protein drinks or jello instant mixtures, you can make 100s of combinations with your Ice Cream!

What is your favorite ice cream flavor? Then, make that favorite flavor with the protein drink.

I am obsessed with coffee ice cream. Guess what I used? Premier Proteins Cafe Latte Protein Drink to make my ice cream.

Protein Ice Cream Ninja Creami

7 DAY CHALLENGE:

You can do seven different flavors for seven days. Or repeat flavors multiple days. Go with how your body feels.

And if you are on a GLP-1 like Mounjaro, Zepbound, Wegovy, etc, I don’t force feed. I eat until I’m full. Sometimes it’s just a few bites and sometimes it is the entire container. But, focusing on my protein on a GLP-1 is always my priority with nutrient dense foods.

1. Day 1: Chocolate Ice Cream (I like Biocare Protein Beverage)
2. Day 2: Mixed Fruit (I like Biocare Protein Beverage)
3. Day 3: Chocolate Peanut Butter (I just use Biocare Protein and 1 scoop of powdered 8 gram protein peanut butter)
4. Day 4: Mixed Fruit w/ splash of full-fat coconut milk
5. Day 5: Chocolate + unsweetened almond milk
6. Day 6: Chocolate + two scoops Carmel Collagen (USE CODE QUEEN)
7. Day 7: Repeat previous day

The great part about this challenge for your high-protein ice cream is you can make so many different homemade ice cream recipes.

I like using two scoops Carmel collagen and/or Chia Collagen (USE CODE: QUEEN).

**I don’t know if the freezing negates the the collagen, but I like the flavoring.

Change out protein for:

• Cashew milk
• Greek Yogurt
• Make protein vanilla ice cream 
• Add almond butter for add in button
• Crumble up protein bar to put in for small chunks
• Cut up dried fruit or fresh fruit
• Add in chia seeds
• Use different type of milk for nut milks

I like using extra ninja creami pint container w/ different color lids to denote different flavors.

Banana Protein Ice Cream

For example, you can switch in the Premier Protein Banana drink with banana jello instant mixture to make a delicious banana ice cream high in protein.

Wild, right?!

Or you could make strawberry chocolate by using the Strawberry Atkins protein drink with chocolate sugar free Jello instant pudding.

Read more about 125 Protein Snack Ideas HERE.

Watch how easy the recipe is to make(WATCH HERE)

5 Tips to Drink More Water – READ HERE